All episodes

Episode · Sep 16, 2026 · 1 hr 36 min

Too Small for the NFL. Then He Broke a Chiefs Record.

with Dexter McCluster

Dexter McCluster is a former NFL running back and returner who trains athletes and coaches running backs at Father Ryan.

Listen on
“I know who I am and I need the ball in my hand.”
Dexter McCluster

Summary

McCluster grew up in Largo, Florida, where he rushed for 2,490 yards and scored 39 touchdowns as a senior. Florida State saw him as a defensive back, while Urban Meyer wanted him as a returner. He chose Ole Miss because he wanted the ball in his hands, even as he became a father at 17. Coaches first used him as a slot receiver. After Houston Nutt moved him to running back, McCluster became the first SEC player to top 1,000 rushing yards and 500 receiving yards in one season. He ran for 282 yards and scored four touchdowns against Tennessee, with Lane Kiffin and Ed Orgeron on the other sideline.

The Chiefs drafted him 36th overall. He describes waiting with his family for the call, buying his parents a house, and returning a punt 94 yards for a franchise record in his first NFL game. A Pro Bowl season led to a contract dispute. Tennessee later released him before the season, and after a run with San Diego and Toronto, McCluster retired more than once. He describes spending long days on the patio and drinking more than he should before his wife reminded him who he was to his family. He returned to training, built McCluster Fit, and now trains athletes and coaches at Father Ryan.

Show notes

Dexter McCluster is five-foot-eight and 165 pounds. Bobby Bowden told him he could play defensive back. Urban Meyer told him he could return kicks. He turned both of them down because he knew who he was, and he needed the ball in his hands.

He went to Ole Miss instead and became the first player in SEC history to rush for 1,000 yards and catch for 500 in the same season. He ran for 282 yards on Lane Kiffin's Tennessee with the coach who recruited him standing on the other sideline, won back-to-back Cotton Bowl MVPs, and got drafted 36th overall by the Chiefs. In his first NFL game, on Monday Night Football, in the rain, he returned a punt 94 yards for a touchdown.

This week I sat down with Dexter to talk about all of it. Becoming a father at 17 and telling his parents within half an hour. Waiting for the draft call on a couch with a Nokia phone and camera crews watching. Buying his mom the house he promised her as a kid. Making the Pro Bowl and then being told he wasn't really a running back or a receiver.

We also get into the part that never makes the highlights. Getting named a captain in Tennessee and then getting cut before the season, the year Derrick Henry showed up. Crying the whole drive home. Three retirements. The months he spent on his patio from six in the morning to six at night, drinking more than he should have, until his wife told him, "Don't forget who you are."

Today Dexter trains athletes, coaches running backs at Father Ryan, and just had his sixth kid, his first boy. We weigh exactly the same. Only one of us has a Chiefs record. Hope you guys enjoy this one.

Follow Dexter: @dextermccluster and @mcclusterfit

Read the transcript

Transcript

Made from YouTube's automatic captions and lightly corrected, so a few words and names may be off. Click a time to play the video from there.

Ken Rideout

All right. Today's special guest, the great Dexter McCluster.

Dexter McCluster

Yes, sir.

Ken Rideout

Man, good to meet you,

Dexter McCluster

Man. Thank you for having me.

Ken Rideout

Ole Miss alum by way of Florida.

Dexter McCluster

Yes. By way of Largo, Florida. Not Largo. Largo.

Ken Rideout

Largo. Yes, sir.

Dexter McCluster

The pride of Largo, Florida.

Ken Rideout

Yeah, man.

When you walked in here, I said to you, man, if you told someone in the street, "Oh, that guy was a big star in the NFL," they they wouldn't believe it. How tall are you?

I'm 5'8" and a quarter, combine tested [clears throat] 2010.

How much you weighing right now?

Dexter McCluster

Uh, right now 165 lbs. same as me.

And guess what? I played at a 168.

Yeah, man.

Ken Rideout

I was just telling you there are positions in the NFL or in football in general, you can kind of slip through the cracks without being super tough. No one would ever say Deion Sanders was like a savage hitter. Right.

Right. But he played the position. He knew how to get around. He knew how to like avoid the he wasn't good at.

Dexter McCluster

Got the job done.

Ken Rideout

Running back, linebacker, defense, you ain't faking your way through. You ass is getting cracked on every play. You got to have some grit, some grind, and you really you can't you can't like you said, you can't fake it. You really you really have to be about what you talk because if you're not, you will get exposed fast, especially at being his size,

Especially a running back, you're making those split-second decisions. Do I put my helmet in his chest or do I give him a juke? If you're juking every time, you're going to get cracked a lot more. If so, you got to like keep them on their toes like, "Oh, is he going to I better go low." And when he goes low, then you're jumping over him and embarrassing him,

Key takeaways

  • Trust the role you know you can play, even when recruiters offer a different path.
  • Preparation helped McCluster turn a chance at running back into a lasting college role.
  • Early responsibility can shape your choices, but you still have to decide what matters to you.
  • A degree can still matter years after the season ends.
  • An athletic career can end before your sense of identity has caught up.
  • Family support and a new routine helped McCluster rebuild after football.

Nowhere to Hide

A weekly letter from Ken Rideout about doing the uncomfortable part, and the reasons we use to avoid it.

It starts with 3 Days, 3 Hard Things: one short story from Ken and one hard thing to do, every day for three days. Then one letter a week.